Mismatched ability in a team

Hi

I am the manager of our new U8s and about to sort out registrations. We have two teams and I have a dilemma.

Team 2 is where i have:

  1. fantastic, always scoring, should be in top team
  2. great player, fast, great defender and midfielder
  3. great player, great gk
  4. great player, can play anywhere 
  5. great player, can play anywhere 
  6. great player, great defender and gk
  7. grear player, can play anywhere
  8. can barely play, can’t kick properly, struggles

player 1 should really be in our top team, but his parents prefer him with the kids he’s played with for over a year and where he has the most fun with

players 2-7  play well together and with player 1 they make a brilliant team

player 8 is a lovely boy and was taken on in the U7s last season just before I became a coach but he simply can’t play very well at all. In every match he struggles, he can’t turn the ball, he goes in the wrong direction, he can barely kick the ball and his ability is just so far removed from even players 2-7, let alone player 1. When in a match the other kids end up having to do all the work as this kid can’t play and with only 4 outfield it’s down to 3 to play. 

Other experienced coaches have seen player 8 play and have said he shouldn’t be in a team in matches as his ability just isn’t up to scratch. But he turns up, has a great attitude and enjoys himself and his family are wonderful.

do I

a) keep him because it’s about having fun at u8 and know that kids develop at different rates

b) tell parents that if he wants to stay they need to increase training - even just playing at home

c) drop him and state that we need a team with equal ability 

  • You keep the player and apply your skills as a coach to support his development which includes but is not limited to conversations with his family in regards to additional support and training 

    development plan 

    regular progress reports 

    1-1 sessions 

    specific skills sessions 

    at this level football is about fun and learning 

  • Thank you.  This is what I have said and as much as he hasn't got the ability, I've said I want to keep him.  But I've had the coaches saying he shouldn't be in the team and the chairman has told me to hold off on sending them the registration.  I just feel that kids develop at different rates and it might one day click.  Bless him, he tries so hard week in, week out.  Always turns up and tries his best and I always give him the same playing time

  • Hi have you part of a club with age groups up to u15? If so ask one of the older ones in that age are they free to do some 1:1 with him on a weekly basis. You could cover say some kit costs and with them work out a monthly plan for the player and set objectives they need to meet. 

  • I would do a and part of b really. Still too early, they're only 7yo, they don't have to be great players at that age. I'm sure the parents can also see and recognise his level in comparison to the rest of the team. Speak to the parents,  if they really do want to help his development, they should seek opportunities to increase his training and they should offer him more football during the week outside the team and depending on what they want to do see how you can help.  No need to kick him out of the team. Trust me, eventually the parents will move/remove him themselves if he doesn't progress. 

  • I too am in a similar situation.

    We are a newly formed U9 team with a 10 player squad.

    None of them have played competitively before.

    Two of which are U8 playing up a year as their ability is on parr with the other 7.

    One of my players in particular is nowhere near the level of the rest.

    Firstly neither myself or Assistant Coach will or want to give up on him. Importantly his parents are fully aware of the difference in ability and recognise what myself and Assistant Coach see. They take him to our academy session once a week, a separate academy which I coach at also, and our team training session.

    He attends every session with a smile on his face without fail every week, his parents are understanding, kind and great people.

    As my Assistant Coach is friends with his parents, the three of us have taken our sons to the park and had a fun but structured mini session to try and advance his skills. Even after all of this he has improved, but so have all of the other players, so there is still gulf in ability.

    You will receive advice from different people both experienced and in-experienced. We have been told by more experienced coaches that the other lads will eventually turn on him if he continuously gives the ball away or or doesn`t pull his weight. If our team are winning and he is introduced to the field and we end up losing because of him, the other players and parents will potentially turn on him and things may get toxic, forcing him to stop enjoying his football and him wanting to leave the team.

    I`ve been told that some kids just aren`t meant for football, no matter how much coaching they receive. I don`t believe in this.

    It is down to myself, Assisant Coach and his parents to come to an inclusive solution to make the best of the situation to prevent anything like that happening.

    Against another academy coaches experienced opinion and judgement we have still registered him and he is our player. 

    We played our first ever friendly yesterday and won 5-0. One of the players was on holiday so we had 9 available and made double subs every 5 mins. As a rule we paired our lower ability player with what can be best described as a box to box player, so that they were on the pitch at the same time at all times. This took the pressure off the lower ability player who did get involved and tried his best which is all you can ask. Some may say he is being carried, and to an extent he is. But none of the other players noticed, especially his box to box pairing who naturally loves to drop back to help in defence / midfield, and also joins the attack.

    We will be speaking to his parents to hopefully agree a plan. We will look to build up his minutes in matches once the season starts when he demonstrates an improvement consistenly without anyone other than his team mates advising him on the pitch. We are trying to be as inclusive as possible, without him feeling left out, at the same time avoiding a toxic situation forming from one of my earlier points.

    We will continue to work with him and hopefully he will become autonomous.

    Good luck!

  • Very difficult situation. I would say use it as your own objective to bring them up to a more "playable" standard. Don't give up on him, imagine being that child left behind. At their age it's about having fun, building their confidence and letting them take their own path in my opinion.